Australian mobile networks win kudos but many black spots remain

Telstra rated best telco in report, but Vodafone is on the up

A report benchmarking the mobile networks in Australia has given high ratings to the country's three telco network operators. The report was released the same day the federal government released applications for a $100 million program that aims remedy poor mobile coverage in regional areas.

“All three of Australia’s mobile networks are strong performers,” according to the <I>CommsDay</I> 2014 Mobile Benchmark, a report prepared by the telecom newsletter and consulting firm P3 Communications.

The magazine praised Telstra's network, saying it “took the ‘best in test’ crown by a clear margin” in the study.

Check out Computerworld Australia’s comparison of the three telcos’ 4G networks, 4G in Australia: The state of the nation.

Telstra launched its 4G LTE network 10 months ahead of Optus, which was ranked an expected second, and has made large investments in its network, the report said.

Telstra got high marks for reliability of both voice and data. The report said that 90 per cent of file downloads were faster than 6Mbps on 4G, and 90 per cent of uploads were faster than 3Mbps in metro areas. However, Telstra lost some points for “relatively long” call setup times.

The report found Optus to be a “very strong second-place contender in the test results.”

“Its consistent capability across voice, 4G and 3G is a testament to the investment and expertise it has dedicated to mobile,” it said.

Optus received high ratings for reliability and performance of 4G data in metro areas. However, outside major metro areas Optus' network was rated less highly for YouTube and the 3G network, the report found.

Optus also scored lower than rivals on speech quality, though reliability was high and the report noted that Optus is the only operator without HD voice.

While Vodafone came in third, the reported noted that the beleaguered telco has greatly improved since the major network issues it suffered in 2009 and 2010.

“Back then, it struggled to meet the capacity and coverage demands of the growing smartphone boom. But the firm spent billions in some serious network upgrades across the following years, and that has shown through in the 2014 test results,” the report said.

The report found Vodafone’s 4G LTE to be fast but less reliable than the other networks.

“It scored very impressive web browsing session times, often comparable to Telstra, and also put in a strong performance on the highways. Lower success ratios were what mainly pulled its 4G score down.”

Similarly, the 3G network had high throughput speeds — 90 per cent of the download tests were faster than 3Mbps — but the network suffered low success ratios for YouTube sessions, the report said.

“For voice, Vodafone scored very highly on speech quality and benefited from short call setup times on highways; however, it took a hit from degraded call success ratios, a heavily weighted part of the test.”

Victoria reports most black spots

Despite the telcos’ efforts, many areas of Australia still have poor or non-existent mobile coverage, according to a map of mobile black spots released by the Department of Communications.

The Department posted a map of 6000 unique mobile black spot locations across the country.

Nearly half of the 6000 black spots identified on the Department of Communications map are located in Victoria.

The southeast of the country, including the regions around Sydney, Melbourne, Canberra and Adelaide, represented about two-thirds of all the black spots.

The areas were nominated by individuals, organisations, community groups, governments and federal members of Parliament.

The department has said that its $100 million Mobile Black Spot program will not be able to patch all 6000 locations. The program’s director, Phillip Smurthwaite, last month predicted the program will produce 250 to 300 new base stations, with each tower able to cover between one and 16 of the identified black spots.

Smurthwaite has said the program will prioritise small communities and major transport routes for new mobile base stations in regional Australia. It also helps if the area puts a little “skin in the game,” including cash or other assistance to build the base station, he has said.

The Victorian government has already put forward large sums of money to the program. The state government has a $40 million program, with some of the money for Wi-Fi on trains and the rest for mobile black spots.

The Western Australian government also has a $40 million black spots program. Slightly more than 500 black spots were identified in WA, representing about 10 per cent of the total number of locations.

Adam Bender covers telco and enterprise tech issues for Computerworld and is the author of dystopian sci-fi novels We, The Watched and Divided We Fall. Follow him on Twitter: @WatchAdam

Follow Computerworld Australia on Twitter: @ComputerworldAU, or take part in the Computerworld conversation on LinkedIn: Computerworld Australia

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags Australiamobile4gtelecomblack spotsmobile coverageDepartment of CommunicationsCommsdaynetwork comparison

More about Department of CommunicationsOptusVodafone

Show Comments